Checked Out: A Bookstore Elopement in NYC
Once upon a time, Madeleine (she/her) had a secret. She had bought a beautiful engagement ring and carried it around for far too long, waiting for the right moment to propose to Elysse (she/her). Little did she know, Elysse had a secret of her own. She had also bought a ring, complete with a plan that involved Central Park, a photographer, and a little bit of cinematic romance.
What neither of them planned for was the architecture aisle at The Strand, fresh off a 6 A.M. flight, where Madeleine whispered, “Doyouwanttomarryme?” There was confusion, then laughter, and then the discovery that there were two rings, which meant Central Park was cancelled and the bookstore won. So when it came time to actually get married, the choice felt obvious. They went back to The Strand, this time upstairs to the Rare Book Room, to turn that whispered proposal into vows.
Chapter One: The Architecture Aisle Proposal
We met in 2021 in the most romantic way possible: Hinge. A prompt about Brandi Carlile and the U.S. Women’s National Soccer Team started it all, and from Madeleine’s point of view, no one had ever looked better than Elysse in a bright orange Carhartt hat, Timberland boots, and a very committed “cool guy” pose.
Thirty days later we were official. Six months after that, roommates. Six months later, homeowners.
In October 2023, a “just because” trip to New York City took us to Elysse’s favorite bookstore, Strand. Madeleine had been carrying a ring for far too long and, with no plan at all, whispered “Doyouwanttomarryme?” in the architecture section after a 6 A.M. flight. There was confusion, then laughter, and then the reveal. Elysse also had a ring and a full Central Park proposal planned. Instead, we left Strand engaged.
On November 5th, 2025, we went back to the Strand Rare Book Room and left as wives. Now we live just outside Nashville with two lovable dogs, one slightly evil but devilishly handsome cat, a songwriter who still owes her wife a song, and a veterinarian who would like everyone to calm down about doodle allergies.
Footnotes on Why We Eloped
We would be lying if we said finances were not the main reason we chose to elope. They absolutely were.
But a very close second was the overwhelming idea of trying to please, accommodate, greet, and thank every single person we love. It felt paralyzing.
At the end of the day, we just wanted to focus on us.
The Rare Book Room
We chose to get married in the exact same place we got engaged!
Fortunately, the marriage ceremony was held privately upstairs in the Strand Rare Book Room. The engagement was just in one of the aisles in the architecture section on the second floor.























Circulated to Our Favorite Readers
We are fairly certain we just texted everyone about our decision to elope.
My mom was over the moon because she loves any excuse to travel. My dad is a country boy through and through, so the city is not exactly his favorite place, but he persevered. Elysse’s parents are born and bred New Yorkers, so they were thrilled for a reason to go back home and, as her mom put it, “eat real Italian food.”
Between the Lines of New York
We started the day with a first look on the rooftop of The Ludlow Hotel and read our personal vows with the city behind us. An HVAC guy had apparently been watching the whole thing and cheered when we finished, which felt very New York.
We finagled an empty subway car for photos on the way to Strand, then had our ceremony. Afterward, our photographer, Sylvie Rosokoff, took us around the city and we were cheered on more times than we can count. Our favorite was a group of girls yelling, “WE LOVE LESBIANS!” outside a flower shop. We ended photos with a slice at Joe’s Pizza, where a little girl told us we looked like princesses.
That night we celebrated at The Four Faced Liar, then had dinner at Palma with our families and wedding cake from Pearl Bitez!
Hardcover Hearts
We are huge book lovers, so getting married in a bookstore already felt very us.
My Uncle Steven officiated and even incorporated books into the ceremony, which, yes, might confirm we have a problem. We also had our first dance to our song, “More of You” by JP Saxe.
The Dream Vendor Index
We found Sylvie Rosokoff by scrolling through blogs that featured NYC weddings, and once we found her there was no going back. Through Sylvie, we connected with our hair and makeup artist at Simple + Sultry and our florist at Flowers By Ellie.
Strand was incredibly easy to work with, and so were Sylvie, Talia, Ellie, and Brooke. Every single one of them made the day feel seamless and special. We are convinced we will never see a more beautiful bouquet, taste a better cake, or look as pretty again, which is why we are so grateful to relive it all through Sylvie’s photos.
The Afterword
It was absolutely the best choice for us.
If we could change anything, we would have stayed longer at The Ludlow Hotel!
Photography by Sylvie Rosokoff
Cake Pearl Bitez
Ceremony Venue Strand Rare Book Room
Florals Flowers By Ellie
Hair & Makeup Simple + Sultry


