Katie and Maddie kiss on a dark dance floor, holding drink cans

Two Proposals, a Quaker Wedding Certificate and a Raleigh Queer Wedding

Katie and Maddie were work friends for almost three years before they started dating. Maddie proposed, Katie proposed back, and with engagement rings from Ring Concierge on both hands, their Raleigh lesbian wedding took the last fall date left at The Merrimon-Wynne House.

After a rehearsal dinner at Hartwell, it was a Raleigh historic home wedding in North Carolina from start to finish: a porch first look, an outdoor ceremony, cocktail hour through the house, then dinner and dancing in the carriage house. They wore gowns by Essense of Australia and Justin Alexander from The Bridal House of Charleston and The Wedding Factor, with shoes from Emmy London and Loeffler Randall. Heritage Floral Design did the flowers, Curated Events the rentals, Empress Stationery the paper and Thru Gabbys Eye the content. Guests signed a Quaker wedding certificate as witnesses, and an ice cream truck pulled up an hour into the dancing.

How do you set a wedding budget youโ€™ll actually stick to?

Know your hard line budget number as early as possible, and then stick to it. We kept track of our budget and expenses in one large spreadsheet.

Book your largest and most important vendors first: venue, photographer, food and beverage, florist, DJ. And keep your wants at the forefront. Tough decisions are much easier when you keep you and your partnerโ€™s wants and needs first.

The wedding planning experience was a lot. It was fun but also overwhelming. We kept things organized with shared notes, schedule planners and a really tight timeline, and we each took on the things we had stronger feelings about.

Katie and Maddie in matching blue and white pajamas sit close together on a white tufted chair by a tall window on their wedding morning
Two white satin wedding gowns hang from a gold-framed mirror in a pale blue room with a tall arched window
A wedding ring flat lay: rings in two blue velvet boxes on woven coasters, surrounded by blue wax seals, ceramic swans and blue hydrangea petals
On the white porch of a historic home, one of the lovers covers her face in surprise as the other, in a veil and gown, stands facing her
Katie and Maddie hold each other's faces and smile, foreheads almost touching, on the porch with fall leaves behind them
Katie and Maddie in white gowns stand apart on a white columned porch holding white and blue hydrangea bouquets, smiling toward each other
Katie and Maddie in white gowns hold blue and white hydrangea bouquets on the porch of The Merrimon-Wynne House at their Raleigh lesbian wedding

How did you go about finding LGBTQ-friendly vendors for a Raleigh wedding?

What was most important to us when picking vendors was that:

  1. They were LGBTQ+ friendly.
  2. They were open to our specific wants and needs.
  3. We felt a genuine connection and level of comfortability when first speaking with them.

We found vendors through our venue and through other vendorsโ€™ referrals, so the day was full of vendors who already knew each other.

We cannot begin to explain how excellent Lori with Imagine This Events is. She is an exceptional wedding coordinator and is worth every penny. We could not be happier with our wedding photos, and would recommend that anyone reading this strongly consider Rae Marshall Photography.

A porch first look (and two dogs) before their Merrimon-Wynne House wedding

We wanted a quiet and peaceful morning, so we had our hair and makeup done together by Mena Garcia Beauty, and only separated when it was time to get into our dresses.

Maddie went downstairs first while I anxiously waited upstairs. Then I took the long trip down the formal staircase and out to the porch, where Maddie was waiting with her eyes closed. When I was finally standing in front of her, I said her name and she opened her eyes. Maddie raised both hands in celebration, and I couldnโ€™t stop smiling.

Once we had calmed down, we could hear our two wonderful dogs in the distance, so we took photos with Walter, our golden retriever, and Freddie, our English setter, before first looks with our dads.

The white Victorian facade of The Merrimon-Wynne House, with the two lovers in gowns on the front porch behind a row of dried hydrangeas
Katie and Maddie in wedding gowns kneel on the lawn with their two dogs, an English setter and a golden retriever wearing blue and white bandanas
An aerial view of the outdoor ceremony on the lawn, with guests seated in rows facing the lovers and their officiant under tall trees
In black and white, the two lovers walk away along a brick path in their gowns and veils, one raising her arm in celebration
Katie and Maddie kiss in the empty ceremony aisle between rows of dark wooden chairs, with the white historic house behind them
Katie and Maddie kiss beneath a large tree, their long trains spread on the grass, with white and blue hydrangeas and a brick building behind them

A ceremony written around Obergefell v. Hodges, with a judge officiating

We wanted to highlight the right to marry, and specifically the Supreme Court decision in Obergefell v. Hodges. That led to me writing the entire ceremony, with Maddieโ€™s help. It was officiated by a judge as a showing of our deep respect for the law.

We approached traditions by remembering one very important thing: there are no rules. We chose to have both of our parents walk us down the aisle. Wedding parties and throwing bouquets werenโ€™t for us. We wanted to focus on each other throughout the day.

Maddie walked first to a string version of โ€œBirds of a Feather.โ€ Then it was my turn, to โ€œSay You Wonโ€™t Let Go.โ€ I almost began to cry when seeing my best friend, but then regained composure upon seeing Maddie waiting for me at the end of the aisle. Once my gaze landed on Maddie, it stayed there. After our first kiss, โ€œLove You for a Long Timeโ€ by Maggie Rogers played as we exited, and we were met with gin and tonics.

A Quaker wedding certificate instead of a guest book

Our most exciting project was our custom Quaker wedding certificate. We ultimately hired a calligrapher from Arizona, Sally Sanders Calligraphy, to complete it. The certificate was our โ€œguest book.โ€ All our guests signed as witnesses to our wedding and in support of our love for one another.

We tasted our appetizers from HL Catering Co before joining our guests for cocktail hour throughout the first floor of the house. There were white and blue hydrangeas in each room, photos from our proposals to each other, and matchbooks and matching napkins with drawings of things we both love.

The white carriage house set for dinner, with chandeliers, pale blue linens, candles and blue and white tableware
Two engraved silver goblets lie on a white surface beside a sprig of green leaves
Katie and Maddie smile at each other as they raise silver goblets at their table, with string lights in the windows behind them
Katie and Maddie raise their glasses at a sweetheart table covered in blue linen and white and blue hydrangeas
A three-tier white wedding cake with piped garlands and a swan topper, on a white stand between glass candle holders
Katie and Maddie kiss on a dark dance floor, holding drink cans
Katie and Maddie in their gowns eat ice cream beside a turquoise Two Roosters Ice Cream truck
At night, Katie and Maddie lean in for a kiss under a clear umbrella
At night on the lawn, the two lovers in gowns hold clear umbrellas overhead, one kissing the other's cheek as she laughs with her arm outstretched

From a Tyler Childers first dance to a sparkler send-off

In the carriage house, we danced our first dance to โ€œIn Your Loveโ€ by Tyler Childers, after fifteen dance classes at Society Hill Dance Academy. Then a bucket list moment for me: my best friend, Devon, and her husband, Matt, performed โ€œDog Yearsโ€ by Maggie Rogers. Maddie and her dad danced to โ€œMy Girl,โ€ and my dad and I danced to โ€œIsnโ€™t She Lovely,โ€ with a surprise ending of โ€œRock Steadyโ€ for the crowd. We cut our cake from LBs Cakes to โ€œBeigeโ€ by Yoke Lore, which had almost become an anthem of our relationship.

The dance floor opened with a reverse anniversary dance. Starting with couples together for over forty years, we joined last as the only couple just married that night.

Randy from Bunn DJ Company was excellent! About an hour into dancing, the Two Roosters Ice Cream truck arrived with six different flavors. We snuck off for ice cream and changed into our getaway outfits: Maddie in a white Polo dress, and me in white boxers and a white long-sleeve polo shirt.

As guests left, we stayed until we were alone with just our DJ and photographer. Randy asked if we were ready and hit play, and we danced our final last dance in the carriage house. Maddie fought back tears while I sang and danced with her.

Our guests were waiting on the brick walkway with sparklers to send us off. We stopped to kiss under the light of the sparklers and then hopped into the getaway car, complete with celebratory cans to announce our entrance to our hotel.


Photography by Rae Marshall Photography

Attire Essense of Australia & Justin Alexander
Cake LBs Cakes
Calligraphy Sally Sanders Calligraphy
Catering HL Catering Co
Content Creator Thru Gabbys Eye
Coordinator Imagine This Events
Dance Lessons Society Hill Dance Academy
DJ Bunn DJ Company
Dress Boutiques The Bridal House of Charleston & The Wedding Factor
Engagement Rings Ring Concierge
Florist Heritage Floral Design
Hair & Makeup Mena Garcia Beauty
Ice Cream Truck Two Roosters Ice Cream
Rehearsal Dinner Hartwell
Rentals Curated Events
Shoes Emmy London & Loeffler Randall
Stationery Empress Stationery
Venue The Merrimon-Wynne House

Similar Posts